Wedding Cake Bakers in Indianapolis
8 cake bakers, with what they charge, what that covers and how far ahead they book.
We read the websites of every cake baker we could
find working in Indianapolis, and pulled out the things couples ask first:
what it costs, what that covers, how far ahead they book, and what actually makes
each one different. Every line below is quoted from their own site and links back
to it.
Of the 12 we looked at, 3 publish
their pricing. That is unusually high for the wedding trade — most Indianapolis
venues publish nothing at all — so this is a genuine comparison rather than a list
of names to email.
Read a starting price as a starting price.
Almost every figure here is the lowest package on the lowest-demand date. Ask what
your date costs before you shortlist on the number.
- Pricing
- individually quoted; example 2-tier round (36 servings) $252 buttercream, 3-tier round (74 servings) $518; $150 deposit holds the date source
- What that covers
- one signature flavor and one filling per tier at base price; free 6-inch first anniversary cake; $30 tasting applied to orders of $500+ booked same day source
- Booking and turnaround
- books 5 to 9 months ahead source
- Area covered
- Central Indiana, including Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield, Zionsville, Greenwood, Avon, Brownsburg, Plainfield, Franklin, Greenfield, Anderson, Danville, and Martinsville source
- Worth knowing
- takes a limited number of weddings each week; all 19 flavors and 9 fillings included at base price with no upcharge source
- Pricing
- No set prices; quoted per order based on servings, flavor and design source
- What that covers
- Complimentary cake tasting source
- Worth knowing
- Takes all orders and quotes by email/online form rather than by phone source
- Pricing
- cake prices not listed; delivery minimum purchase $20 with delivery charge based on round-trip mileage source
- What that covers
- custom design work with the couple, including from their own design source
- Booking and turnaround
- books weddings at least 2-3 months ahead source
- Area covered
- Indianapolis southside and Greater Indianapolis source
- Worth knowing
- fondant is made from white and dark chocolate rather than gum paste source
- Pricing
- Not published on their site. You will have to ask.
- Worth knowing
- German bakery and pastry shop operating within a German cafe, grocery and gift shop source
- Pricing
- Not published on their site. You will have to ask.
- Area covered
- ships cakes, pies and cookies nationwide at a flat rate; shops in Broad Ripple Village, Carmel City Center and Disney's BoardWalk source
- Worth knowing
- has a dedicated Concierge Wedding Team that responds to inquiry forms within two business days source
- Pricing
- Not published on their site. You will have to ask.
- Booking and turnaround
- Wedding team responds to inquiries within two business days source
- Area covered
- Ships cakes, pies and cookies nationwide at a flat shipping rate source
- Worth knowing
- Also hosts private events at its own restaurants, alongside the bakery source
- Pricing
- Not published on their site. You will have to ask.
- Worth knowing
- Specializes in Latino flavors and Mexican desserts source
- Pricing
- Not published on their site. You will have to ask.
- Worth knowing
- Owner Sandy is the only female certified Master Baker in Indiana; baked goods made without preservatives or chemicals source
Ask about a cake baker in Indianapolis
We have not placed a cake baker in Indianapolis yet, so we cannot promise a reply from one. Tell us what you are looking for and we will come back to you when we have someone worth recommending — and your free wedding page is ready either way.
A free page for your guests
Your guests look up their table, see the schedule, and upload photos to the
reception slideshow — from their phones, no app. Free, and it takes a few minutes to set up.
Make your free page